<!-- canonical: https://klappy.dev/page/canon/methods/choosing-the-right-narrative-container -->
<!-- content: klappy/klappy.dev@b750d7d3aa85a3e5ed6d1e2b24d63471f3df4bac -->

# Method: Choosing the Right Narrative Container

> Not every insight belongs in the same kind of document.

## Description

This method exists to prevent epistemic drift caused by placing ideas in the wrong narrative container. In ODD, **form is not decoration**. It determines how authority is interpreted and where meaning accumulates.

When writing feels forced or confusing, the issue is often not the content but the container.

---

## The Three Containers

### Canon
Use when:
- an invariant constraint is being stated
- violations must be disallowed
- authority is intentional

Do not use when:
- ambiguity is required
- experience matters more than rules

---

### Apocrypha Fragment
Use when:
- a failure mode must be preserved
- explanation would create authority
- the system needs to absorb pressure without resolving it

Apocrypha fragments:
- do not instruct
- do not warn
- do not explain
- do not close loops

They exist because deletion would reduce coherence.

---

### Cinematic Retelling
Use when:
- experiential truth matters
- temporal unfolding is important
- emotional or human impact needs preservation

Cinematic retellings:
- have no governing authority
- must never be cited as canon
- exist to preserve memory, not rules

---

## Diagnostic Signals

- If writing feels **forced**, the container is likely wrong.
- If writing feels **inevitable**, the container is likely correct.
- If a document feels **too persuasive**, it is probably in the wrong form.

When in doubt, do not publish. Reclassify first.
